Market power consolidation and M&A success: A study of US-American and German utility takeovers

Robert Fraunhoffer, Andreas Freytag, Dirk Schiereck


A wave of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) was observed in the North American and European energy utilities market. We analyze the impact of these M&A transactions on market power, studying 139 takeovers of energy utilities by applying event study methodology. Stock price reactions of acquiring and target firms as well as of their competitors are used to detect changes of market power. While we do not find any significant results pointing in this direction for transactions in the US, our findings indicate that the potential to increase market power is indeed an important motive for takeovers within the German energy utilities market.


Energy utilities; Mergers and acquisitions; Market power.

Full Text:



Andrade, G., Mitchell, M., Staffort, E., 2001. New Evidence and Perspectives on Mergers. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(2): 103-120.

Bacon, F.W., Shin, T.S., Murphy, N.B., 1997. Horizontal Merger Effects on Financial and Operating Performance: A Probit Analysis of Rural Electric Utilities. Journal of Energy Finance & Development, 2(2): 213-227.

Baum, J.A.C., Korn, H.J., 1999. Dynamics of Dyadic Competitive Interaction. Strategic Management Journal, 20(3): 251-278.

Bartunek, K., Jessell, K., Madura, J., 1993. Are acquisitions by utility firms beneficial?. Applied Economics, 25(11): 1401-1408.

Becker-Blease, J. R., Goldberg, L. G., Kaen, F. R., 2008. Mergers and Acquisitions as a Response to the Deregulation of the Electric Power Industry: Value Creation or Value Destruction. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 33: 21-53.

Bental, B., Deffains, B., Demougin, D., 2012. Credibility and Monitoring: Outsourcing as a Commitment Device. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 21(1): 31-52.

Berry, S.K., 2000. Excess Returns in Electric Utility Mergers during the Transition to Competition. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 18(2): 175-188.

Bhattacharyya, S., Nain, A., 2011. Horizontal Acquisitions and Buying Power: A Product Market Analysis. Journal of Financial Economics, 99(1): 97-115.

Bilotkach, V., 2011. Multimarket Contact and Intensity of Competition: Evidence from an Airline Merger. Review of Industrial Organization, 38(1): 95-115.

Borenstein, S., Bushnell, J., Wolak, F., 2002. Measuring Market Inefficiencies in California's Restructured Wholesale Electricity Market. American Economic Review, 92(5): 1376-1405.

Bouwman, H. C., Fuller, K., Nain, A. S., 2012. Market Valuation and Acquisition Quality: Empirical Evidence. The Review of Financial Studies, 25(9): 633-679.

Brown, S.J., Warner, J.B., 1980. Measuring Security Price Performance. Journal of Financial Economics, 8(3): 205-258.

Brown, S.J., Warner, J.B., 1985. Using Daily Stock Returns - The Case of Event Studies. Journal of Financial Economics, 14(2): 3-31.

Bruner, R., 2004. Where M&A Pays and Where it Strays: A Survey of Research. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 16(4): 63-76.

Burns, R., Erwin, G., Messina, F., Nail, L., 1998. Value Creation in Bundling Utility Mergers: A Corporate Focus Anomaly. Journal of Energy Finance & Development, 3(2): 185-192.

Cai, J., Song, H.M., Walkling, R.A., 2012. Anticipation, Acquisitions, and Bidder Returns: Industry Shocks and the Transfer of Information across Rivals. The Review of Financial Studies, 25(9): 2242-2285.

Corrado, J.C., 2011. Event Studies: A Methodology Review. Accounting & Finance, 51(1): 207-234.

Eckbo, B.E., 1983. Horizontal Mergers, Collusion, and Stockholder Wealth. Journal of Financial Economics, 11(3): 241-273.

Eckbo, B.E., 1985. Mergers and the Market Concentration Doctrine: Evidence From the Capital Market. Journal of Business, 58(3): 325-349.

Eckbo, B.E., Wier, P., 1985. Antimerger Policy under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act: a Reexamination of the Market Power Hypothesis. Journal of Law and Economics, 28(1): 119-149.

Edwards, C.D., 1955. Conglomerate Bigness as a Source of Power, in National Bureau of Economic Research (Eds.), Business Concentration and Price Policy. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 331-359.

Energy Information Administration, 2001. The Changing Structure of the Electric Power Industry: An Update. National Energy Information Center, Washington D.C.

Energy Information Administration, 2002. Electric Power Industry Financial Statistics.

Energy Information Administration, 2003a. Status of Natural Gas Residential Choice Programs by State As of December 2003.

Energy Information Administration, 2003b. Status of State Electric Industry Restructuring Activity. regmap.html.

Energy Information Administration, 2003c. U.pp Electric Utility Sales, Revenue, and Average Revenue Per Kilowatthour (Retail Price).

Energy Information Administration, 2005. U.pp Electric Utilities.

European Commission, 1997. Verordnung (EWG) Nr. 4064/89 Über Fusionsverfahren. European Commission, Brussels.

European Commission, 2004. Third Benchmarking Report on the Implementation of the Internal Electricity and Gas Market. European Commission, Brussels.

Fabrizio, K. R., Rose, N. L., Wolfram, C. D., 2007. Do Markets Reduce Costs? Assessing the Impact of Regulatory Restructuring on US Electric Generation Efficiency, American Economic Review, 97(4): 1250-1277.

Fee, C.E., Thomas, S., 2004. Sources of Gains in Horizontal Mergers: Evidence from Customer, Supplier, and Rival Firms. Journal of Financial Economics, 74(3): 423-460.

Fraunhoffer, R, Schiereck, D., 2012a. Consolidation of the Energy Sector, Potential Synergies, and Realized Shareholder Value – Survey and New Insights from Top Managers’ Perceptions. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 10(2): 68-79.

Fraunhoffer, R., Schiereck, D., 2012b. Consolidation and Communication in European Energy Markets. International Journal of Energy Sector Management, 6(4): 534-557.

Fuller, K., Netter, J., Stegemoller, M., 2002. What Do Returns to Acquiring Firms Tell Us? Evidence From Firms That Make Many Acquisitions. Journal of Finance, 57(4): 1763-1793.

Gaughan, P., 2002. Mergers, Acquisitions, and Corporate Restructuring, third ed. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons Inc..

Ghosh, A., Lee, C.W.J., 2000. Abnormal Returns and Expected Managerial Performance of Target Firms. Financial Management, 29(1): 40-52.

Haleblian, J., Finkelstein, S., 1999. The Influence of Organizational Acquisition Experience on Acquisition Performance: A Behavioral Learning Perspective. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(1): 29-56.

Hankir, Y., Rauch, C., Umber, M.P., 2011. Bank M&A: A Market Power Story. Journal of Banking and Finance, 35(9): 2341-2354.

Hieronymus, W.H., Henderson, J.S., Berry, C.A., 2002. Market Power Analysis of the Electricity Generation Sector. Energy Law Journal, 23(1): 1-50.

Hildebrandt, E., 2001. Further Analyses of the Exercise and Cost Impacts of Market Power in California´s Wholesale Energy Market. Working Paper. Folsom: California Independent System Operator.

Hubbard, R.G., Palia, D., 1999. A Re-Examination of the Conglomerate Merger Wave in the 1960s: An Internal Capital Markets View. Journal of Finance, 54(3): 1131-1152.

Isser, S.N., 2004. Electricity Deregulation: Kilowatts for Nothing and Your BTUs for Free. Review of Policy Research, 20(2): 219-238.

Jayachandran, S., Gimeno, J., Varadarajan, P.R., 1999. The Theory of Multimarket Competition: A Synthesis and Implications for Marketing Strategy. Journal of Marketing, 63(3): 49-66.

Jensen, M.C., 1983. Takeovers: Folklore and Science. Harvard Business Review, 4(2): 6-27.

Jensen, M.C., 1986. Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow, Corporate Finance, and Takeovers. American Economic Review, 76(2): 323-329.

Jensen, M.C., 1993. The Modern Industrial Revolution, Exit, and the Failure of Internal Control Systems. Journal of Finance, 48(3): 831-880.

Joskow, P., Kahn, E., 2001. Identifying the Exercise of Market Power: Refining the Estimates. Working Paper. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge.

Joskow, P., Kahn, E., 2002. A Quantitative Analysis of Pricing Behavior in California’s Wholesale Electricity Market during Summer 2000: The Final Word, Cambridge.

Kiesling, L., 2004. The North American Blackout and Electricity Policy: Alternatives to Transmission Construction. Economic Affairs, 24(1): 53-57.

Kim, E.H., Singal, V., 1993. Mergers and Market Power - Evidence From the Airline Industry. American Economic Review, 83(3): 549-569.

Kutlu, L., Sickles, R.C., 2011. Estimation of Market Power in the Presence of Firm inefficiency. Journel of Econometrics, 168(1): 141-155.

Kwoka, J., 2006. Electric Power Distribution: Economies of Scale, Mergers, and Restructuring. Applied Economics, 37: 2373-2386.

Leeth, J.D., Borg, J.R., 2000. The Impact of Takeovers on Shareholder Wealth During the 1920s Merger Wave. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 35(2): 217-238.

Leggio, K. B., Lien, D., 2000. Mergers in the electric utility industry in a deregulatory environment. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 17(1): 69-85.

Manne, H.G., 1969. Mergers and the Market for Corporate Control. Journal of Political Economy, 73(2): 110-120.

McLaughlin, R. M., Mehran, H., 1995. Regulation and the Market for Corporate Control - Hostile Tender Offers for Electric and Gas Utilities. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 8(2): 181-204.

Mitchell, M.L., Mulherin, J.H., 1996. The Impact of Industry Shocks on Takeover and Restructuring Activity. Journal of Financial Economics, 41(2): 193-229.

Moeller, S., Schlingemann, F., Stulz, R., 2005. Wealth Destruction on a Massive Scale? A Study of Acquiring-Firm Returns in the Recent Merger Wave. The Journal of Finance, 60: 757-782.

Mulherin, J.H., Boone, A.L., 2000. Comparing Acquisitions and Divestitures. Journal of Corporate Finance, 6(2): 117-139.

Pryor, F.L., 2001. Dimensions of the Worldwide Merger Boom. Journal of Economic Issues, 35(4): 825-840.

Ramos-Real, F. J., Tovar, B., Iootty, M., Fagundes de Almeida, E., Queiroz Pinto Jr., H., 2009. The Evolution and Main Determinants of Productivity in Brazilian Electricity Distribution 1998–2005: An Empirical Analysis. Energy Economics, 31: 298-305.

Schmid, A., Sanchez, C., Goldberg, S., 2012. M&A today: Great challenges, but great opportunities. Journal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 23(2): 6-8.

Seth, A., 1990. Value Creation in Acquisitions: A Re-Examination of Performance Issues. Strategic Management Journal, 11(2): 99-115.

Seth, A., Song, K.P., Pettit, R.R., 2002. Value Creation and Destruction in Cross-Border Acquisitions: An Empirical Analysis of Foreign Acquisitions of Utility Firms. Strategic Management Journal, 23(10): 921-940.

Sharur, H., 2005. Industry Structure and Horizontal Takeovers: Analysis of Wealth Effects on Rivals, Suppliers, and Corporate Customers. Journal of Financial Economics, 76(1): 61-98.

Singal, V., 1996. Airline Mergers and Multimarket Contact. Managerial & Decision Economics, 17(6): 559-574.

Song, M.H., Walkling, R.A., 2000. Abnormal Returns to Rivals of Acquisition Targets: A Test of the 'Acquisition Probability Hypothesis'. Journal of Financial Economics, 55(2): 143-171.

Steiner, P.O., 1975. Mergers: Motives, Effects, Policies, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI.

Stigler, G.J., 1950. Monopoly and Oligopoly by Merger. American Economic Review, 40(2): 23-34.

Stillman, R., 1983. Examining Antitrust Policy Towards Horizontal Mergers. Journal of Financial Economics, 11(1-4): 225-240.

Teece, D.J., Pisano, G., Shuen, A., 1997. Dynamic Capabilities and Strategic Management. Strategic Management Journal, 18(7): 509-537.

Thomas, Thomas W., 2005. Unternehmenszusammenschlüsse in der Energieversorgung – Empirische Analyse der Übernahmewelle der 1990er Jahre in Nordamerika und Europa. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag.

Tombak, M.M., 2002. Mergers to Monopoly. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 11(3): 513-546.

Trautwein, F., 1990. Merger Motives and Merger Prescriptions. Strategic Management Journal, 11(4): 283-295.

Varaiya, N.P., 1988. The 'Winner´s Curse' Hypothesis and Corporate Takeovers. Managerial and Decision Economics, 9(3): 209-219.

Verde, S., 2008. Everybody Merges with Somebody – The wave of M&As in the Energy Industry and the EU Merger Policy. Energy Policy, 36: 1125-1133.

Weston, J.F., Chung, K.S., Siu, J.A., 1997. Takeovers, Restructuring, and Corporate Governance. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.


Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2014 Robert Fraunhoffer, Andreas Freytag, Dirk Schiereck


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.


If you find difficulties in submitting manuscript please forward your doc file to Our support team will assist you in submission process and other technical matters. Please note that documents uploaded by yourself are reviewed more quickly than replies by e-mail.

In order to get notifications on inbox please add  this domain in your email safe list.


ISSN 2379-9463(Print)
ISSN 2379-9471(Online)